I have just been through this with my 2310.
I have tried from a 19 pitch to a 16 pitch some three blade( Odd number pitch) and some four blade (Even number pitch). I think the sweet spot for this boat is a 15 (in my case) x 17 pitch.
So if a four blade is your desire I would suggest an 18 pitch. The 16 is great out of the hole but cuts the top end speed. It is a trade off. You should go with the largest diameter that you can fit.
Stay away from the piranha props. I was advised by DALE that "the Parker is too heavy for them"*. So I tried it anyway........ Yep broke a blade off during acceleration! It is a great concept, just for smaller boats. Good news is that they took it back no questions.
Good luck.
*He was right.