RLA69
We are sorry you are experiencing a problem with your prop, but maybe I can give you some insight into what is going on.
When you went from a three bladed prop to a four blade, you obviously added blade surface area. That is counter to what you need to have on a prop that will back more effectively. Actually, the best prop for backing up would be a single bladed prop. Of course no-one makes one of those. So the reality is, your three blade prop should have backed better than your four blade. Everything you do when propping a boat has a trade off. You can get a better hole shot but lose top end speed. You can get more speed but probably lose hole shot and bite in corners.
You seem to be very concerned about maneuverability around docks. The only way you are going to get there is with a prop that, most likely, will suffer in hole shot, mid-range, and rough water handling. The same grip that most people talk about when it concerns a prop does not equate to better grip while in reverse. When spinning a prop in reverse, you are using the back of the blade to move the boat. There is nothing on the back of a prop blade to assist with gripping the water like there is on the front of the blade (cupping). The cupping that helps with prop “grip” while going forward, causes aeration while backing.
Additionally, with a wide flat transom, like those on Parkers, there are other issues that enter into the picture. You said that you have a bracket on your boat. When backing a boat with a bracket, the reverse thrust cannot get under the boat as easily as it could without the bracket, if mounted low enough. All of that water hits the transom and actually works against the motor and prop. That is why it is better to trim out while backing. The transom also acts like a wall and resists any change in direction.
I think the best you are going to be able to do is to find a prop that has a reasonable trade off to help with backing, but still provide good performance in other areas. My suggestion would be to find a three bladed prop that will get the right rpm’s at top speed and still provide good rough water performance and mid-range cruising. At that point, you will likely have to live with the backing characteristics of the boat/motor/prop setup.
If you would like to talk with one of our tech support specialists, please call PowerTech! at 1-800-736-7767.
George