O.K. here is an update on my hatch anyway. I can't call it watertight yet, but very close and I believe it will be.
I moved my hinges to the top or front side of the hatch instead of the starboard side. I purchased two TACO latches that lock down and pull the hatch tight. I tried to put a silicone rubber seal on the bottom of the hatch and I just couldn't get that to work. So just to see how well it would work I got some 3/16" foam weather strip and put it on the inside of the hatch opening. I was very pleased at the seal and I'm sure I can get this to work. I did have a little water leak in but I think that's leaking under and through the latches because I have not sealed them yet. I'm waiting until I'm sure everything works right to insulate the hatch lid. I could actually see that the underside of the latch was wet when I opened it and there is no way it could get wet unless it came through and under the latch
I need to fit it better on the hinge side as it is too tight and peals up the seal, but it does work. I think if I use a thinner silicone rubber seal, it will get the job done. I may have to sand or grind down the one side under the hinges I’ll have to wait and see. Anyway I’m almost done with my fishbox project and then I will post the whole job.
P.S. I’m not sure I would ever trust the seal to store dry goods because there is no lip to guarantee water can’t just run in. I mean for things like a generator or something that just can’t get wet.